How should multiple records in the entity bulk download be interpreted?

Looking at the bulk download for organizations from here: https://permid.org/download

I find multiple records for the same PermID. How should I reconcile conflicting information across these records? Does the record with the highest line number the file have the correct data? Here are some example records for PermID = 4296182513.

194571:<https://permid.org/1-4296182513&gt;
194572- a tr-org:Organization ;
194573- mdaas:HeadquartersAddress "2479 E Bayshore Rd Ste 195\nPALO ALTO\nCALIFORNIA\n94303-3230\nUnited States\n"^^xsd:string ;
194574- mdaas:RegisteredAddress "112 North Curry St\nCARSON CITY\nNEVADA\n89703\nUnited States\n"^^xsd:string ;
194575- tr-common:hasPermId "4296182513"^^xsd:string ;
194576- tr-fin:hasOrganizationPrimaryQuote
194577- <https://permid.org/1-21539925349&gt; ;
194578- tr-fin:hasPrimaryInstrument <https://permid.org/1-8589997596&gt; ;
194579- tr-org:hasActivityStatus tr-org:statusActive ;
194580- tr-org:hasHeadquartersFaxNumber
194581- "14088241543"^^xsd:string ;
194582- tr-org:hasHeadquartersPhoneNumber
194583- "14087022167"^^xsd:string ;
194584- tr-org:hasHoldingClassification
194585- tr-org:publiclyHeld ;
194586- tr-org:hasLatestOrganizationFoundedDate
194587- "1999-04-08T00:00:00Z"^^xsd:dateTime ;
194588- tr-org:hasPrimaryBusinessSector
194589- <https://permid.org/1-4294952830&gt; ;
194590- tr-org:hasPrimaryEconomicSector
194591- <https://permid.org/1-4294952723&gt; ;
194592- tr-org:hasPrimaryIndustryGroup <https://permid.org/1-4294952829&gt; ;
194593- tr-org:isIncorporatedIn <http://sws.geonames.org/6252001/&gt; ;
194594- fibo-be-le-cb:isDomiciledIn <http://sws.geonames.org/6252001/&gt; ;
194595- vcard:hasURL <http://www.sysorex.com/&gt; ;
194596- vcard:organization-name "Sysorex Global"^^xsd:string .
--
266704:<https://permid.org/1-4296182513&gt;
266705- a tr-org:Organization ;
266706- mdaas:HeadquartersAddress "2479 E Bayshore Rd Ste 195\nPALO ALTO\nCALIFORNIA\n94303\nUnited States\n"^^xsd:string ;
266707- mdaas:RegisteredAddress "112 N Curry St\nCARSON CITY\nNEVADA\n89703-4934\nUnited States\n"^^xsd:string ;
266708- tr-common:hasPermId "4296182513"^^xsd:string ;
266709- tr-fin:hasOrganizationPrimaryQuote
266710- <https://permid.org/1-21539925349&gt; ;
266711- tr-fin:hasPrimaryInstrument <https://permid.org/1-8589997596&gt; ;
266712- tr-org:hasActivityStatus tr-org:statusActive ;
266713- tr-org:hasHeadquartersFaxNumber
266714- "14088241543"^^xsd:string ;
266715- tr-org:hasHeadquartersPhoneNumber
266716- "14087022167"^^xsd:string ;
266717- tr-org:hasHoldingClassification
266718- tr-org:publiclyHeld ;
266719- tr-org:hasIPODate "2014-04-10T04:00:00Z"^^xsd:dateTime ;
266720- tr-org:hasLatestOrganizationFoundedDate
266721- "1999-04-08T00:00:00Z"^^xsd:dateTime ;
266722- tr-org:hasPrimaryBusinessSector
266723- <https://permid.org/1-4294952830&gt; ;
266724- tr-org:hasPrimaryEconomicSector
266725- <https://permid.org/1-4294952723&gt; ;
266726- tr-org:hasPrimaryIndustryGroup <https://permid.org/1-4294952829&gt; ;
266727- tr-org:isIncorporatedIn <http://sws.geonames.org/6252001/&gt; ;
266728- fibo-be-le-cb:isDomiciledIn <http://sws.geonames.org/6252001/&gt; ;
266729- vcard:hasURL <http://sysorex.com/&gt; ;
266730- vcard:organization-name "Sysorex Global"^^xsd:string .
--
35184710:<https://permid.org/1-4296182513&gt;
35184711- a tr-org:Organization ;
35184712- mdaas:HeadquartersAddress "2479 E Bayshore Rd Ste 195\nPALO ALTO\nCALIFORNIA\n94303-3245\nUnited States\n"^^xsd:string ;
35184713- mdaas:RegisteredAddress "112 North Curry Street\nCARSON CITY\nNEVADA\n89703-4934\nUnited States\n"^^xsd:string ;
35184714- tr-common:hasPermId "4296182513"^^xsd:string ;
35184715- tr-fin:hasOrganizationPrimaryQuote
35184716- <https://permid.org/1-21539925349&gt; ;
35184717- tr-fin:hasPrimaryInstrument <https://permid.org/1-8589997596&gt; ;
35184718- tr-org:hasActivityStatus tr-org:statusActive ;
35184719- tr-org:hasHeadquartersFaxNumber
35184720- "14088241543"^^xsd:string ;
35184721- tr-org:hasHeadquartersPhoneNumber
35184722- "14087022167"^^xsd:string ;
35184723- tr-org:hasHoldingClassification
35184724- tr-org:publiclyHeld ;
35184725- tr-org:hasIPODate "2014-04-10T04:00:00Z"^^xsd:dateTime ;
35184726- tr-org:hasLatestOrganizationFoundedDate
35184727- "1999-04-08T00:00:00Z"^^xsd:dateTime ;
35184728- tr-org:hasPrimaryBusinessSector
35184729- <https://permid.org/1-4294952830&gt; ;
35184730- tr-org:hasPrimaryEconomicSector
35184731- <https://permid.org/1-4294952723&gt; ;
35184732- tr-org:hasPrimaryIndustryGroup <https://permid.org/1-4294952829&gt; ;
35184733- tr-org:isIncorporatedIn <http://sws.geonames.org/6252001/&gt; ;
35184734- fibo-be-le-cb:isDomiciledIn <http://sws.geonames.org/6252001/&gt; ;
35184735- vcard:hasURL <http://sysorex.com/&gt; ;
35184736- vcard:organization-name "Inpixon"^^xsd:string .
--
37577944:<https://permid.org/1-4296182513&gt;
37577945- a tr-org:Organization ;
37577946- mdaas:HeadquartersAddress "2479 E Bayshore Rd Ste 195\nPALO ALTO\nCALIFORNIA\n94303-3245\nUnited States\n"^^xsd:string ;
37577947- mdaas:RegisteredAddress "112 N Curry St\nCARSON CITY\nNEVADA\n89703-4934\nUnited States\n"^^xsd:string ;
37577948- tr-common:hasPermId "4296182513"^^xsd:string ;
37577949- tr-fin:hasOrganizationPrimaryQuote
37577950- <https://permid.org/1-21539925349&gt; ;
37577951- tr-fin:hasPrimaryInstrument <https://permid.org/1-8589997596&gt; ;
37577952- tr-org:hasActivityStatus tr-org:statusActive ;
37577953- tr-org:hasHeadquartersFaxNumber
37577954- "14088241543"^^xsd:string ;
37577955- tr-org:hasHeadquartersPhoneNumber
37577956- "14087022167"^^xsd:string ;
37577957- tr-org:hasHoldingClassification
37577958- tr-org:publiclyHeld ;
37577959- tr-org:hasIPODate "2002-05-29T04:00:00Z"^^xsd:dateTime ;
37577960- tr-org:hasLatestOrganizationFoundedDate
37577961- "1999-04-08T00:00:00Z"^^xsd:dateTime ;
37577962- tr-org:hasPrimaryBusinessSector
37577963- <https://permid.org/1-4294952830&gt; ;
37577964- tr-org:hasPrimaryEconomicSector
37577965- <https://permid.org/1-4294952723&gt; ;
37577966- tr-org:hasPrimaryIndustryGroup <https://permid.org/1-4294952829&gt; ;
37577967- tr-org:isIncorporatedIn <http://sws.geonames.org/6252001/&gt; ;
37577968- fibo-be-le-cb:isDomiciledIn <http://sws.geonames.org/6252001/&gt; ;
37577969- vcard:hasURL <https://inpixon.com/&gt; ;
37577970- vcard:organization-name "Inpixon"^^xsd:string .
--

Best Answer

  • @amarder

    The development team has acknowledged this issue. They will fix this issue but at the moment there is no specific date for the fix.

    For duplicated records, you should take the last one with the highest line number.

Answers

  • @amarder

    The new version of Organization file is available on 29 Oct 2017 (OpenPermID-bulk-organization-20171029_070342.ttl). I have verified it and there is no duplicated entry for 1-429618251.

    Could you please use the new file and let us know the result?

  • @jirapongse.phuriphanvichai

    Thanks for following up. Looking at the new file, I agree there is a single entry for 1-4296182513. Unfortunately, other PermIDs still have multiple entries. For instance, here are the four entries for 1-5045849264:

    433502:<https://permid.org/1-5045849264&gt;
    433503- a tr-org:Organization ;
    433504- mdaas:HeadquartersAddress "Singapore\n"^^xsd:string ;
    433505- tr-common:hasPermId "5045849264"^^xsd:string ;
    433506- tr-org:hasActivityStatus tr-org:statusActive ;
    433507- tr-org:hasLEI "549300DYX0UTSCF6MS89"^^xsd:string ;
    433508- fibo-be-le-cb:isDomiciledIn <http://sws.geonames.org/1880251/&gt; ;
    433509- vcard:hasURL <http://pnd-hardware.com/&gt; ;
    433510- vcard:organization-name "PND Hardware & Trading Pte Ltd"^^xsd:string .
    --
    558416:<https://permid.org/1-5045849264&gt;
    558417- a tr-org:Organization ;
    558418- mdaas:HeadquartersAddress "13 Gul Link\n629383\nSingapore\n"^^xsd:string ;
    558419- mdaas:RegisteredAddress "13 Gul Link\n629383\nSingapore\n"^^xsd:string ;
    558420- tr-common:hasPermId "5045849264"^^xsd:string ;
    558421- tr-org:hasActivityStatus tr-org:statusActive ;
    558422- tr-org:hasHeadquartersFaxNumber
    558423- "6565666298"^^xsd:string ;
    558424- tr-org:hasHeadquartersPhoneNumber
    558425- "6565656233"^^xsd:string ;
    558426- tr-org:hasLEI "549300DYX0UTSCF6MS89"^^xsd:string ;
    558427- tr-org:hasRegisteredFaxNumber "6565666298"^^xsd:string ;
    558428- tr-org:hasRegisteredPhoneNumber
    558429- "6565656233"^^xsd:string ;
    558430- tr-org:isIncorporatedIn <http://sws.geonames.org/1880251/&gt; ;
    558431- fibo-be-le-cb:isDomiciledIn <http://sws.geonames.org/1880251/&gt; ;
    558432- vcard:hasURL <http://pnd-hardware.com/&gt; ;
    558433- vcard:organization-name "PND Hardware & Trading Pte Ltd"^^xsd:string .
    --
    27452944:<https://permid.org/1-5045849264&gt;
    27452945- a tr-org:Organization ;
    27452946- mdaas:HeadquartersAddress "13 Gul Link\n629383\nSingapore\n"^^xsd:string ;
    27452947- mdaas:RegisteredAddress "13 Gul Link\n629383\nSingapore\n"^^xsd:string ;
    27452948- tr-common:hasPermId "5045849264"^^xsd:string ;
    27452949- tr-org:hasActivityStatus tr-org:statusActive ;
    27452950- tr-org:hasHeadquartersFaxNumber
    27452951- "6565666298"^^xsd:string ;
    27452952- tr-org:hasHeadquartersPhoneNumber
    27452953- "6565656233"^^xsd:string ;
    27452954- tr-org:hasLEI "549300DYX0UTSCF6MS89"^^xsd:string ;
    27452955- tr-org:hasRegisteredFaxNumber "6565666298"^^xsd:string ;
    27452956- tr-org:hasRegisteredPhoneNumber
    27452957- "6565656233"^^xsd:string ;
    27452958- tr-org:isIncorporatedIn <http://sws.geonames.org/1880251/&gt; ;
    27452959- fibo-be-le-cb:isDomiciledIn <http://sws.geonames.org/1880251/&gt; ;
    27452960- vcard:hasURL <http://pnd-hardware.com/&gt; ;
    27452961- vcard:organization-name "PND Hardware & Trading Pte Ltd"^^xsd:string .
    --
    38847298:<https://permid.org/1-5045849264&gt;
    38847299- a tr-org:Organization ;
    38847300- mdaas:HeadquartersAddress "13 Gul Link\n629383\nSingapore\n"^^xsd:string ;
    38847301- mdaas:RegisteredAddress "13 Gul Link\n629383\nSingapore\n"^^xsd:string ;
    38847302- tr-common:hasPermId "5045849264"^^xsd:string ;
    38847303- tr-org:hasActivityStatus tr-org:statusActive ;
    38847304- tr-org:hasHeadquartersFaxNumber
    38847305- "6565666298"^^xsd:string ;
    38847306- tr-org:hasHeadquartersPhoneNumber
    38847307- "6565656233"^^xsd:string ;
    38847308- tr-org:hasLEI "549300DYX0UTSCF6MS89"^^xsd:string ;
    38847309- tr-org:hasRegisteredFaxNumber "6565666298"^^xsd:string ;
    38847310- tr-org:hasRegisteredPhoneNumber
    38847311- "6565656233"^^xsd:string ;
    38847312- tr-org:isIncorporatedIn <http://sws.geonames.org/1880251/&gt; ;
    38847313- fibo-be-le-cb:isDomiciledIn <http://sws.geonames.org/1880251/&gt; ;
    38847314- vcard:hasURL <http://pnd-hardware.com/&gt; ;
    38847315- vcard:organization-name "PND Hardware & Trading Pte Ltd"^^xsd:string .

  • @amarder

    Thank you so much for the information.

    I will contact the support team to verify it.

  • I found the latest version of the bulk organization file has one only entry for 1-5045849264. Therefore, this issue has been resolved.